For many homeowners, maintaining a pristine lawn is a matter of pride. Keeping your garden looking its best often starts with choosing the right lawnmower, but should you go petrol or electric?
In this article, we'll delve into the differences between electric and petrol lawnmowers, so that you can make an informed decision. Keep reading to learn more…
A history of the humble lawnmower
The lawnmower has an interesting history that dates back to the early 19th century. Before lawnmowers, maintaining a neat lawn was a laborious task carried out with scythes and shears, which required considerable effort.
The breakthrough came in 1830, when Edwin Beard Budding, an English engineer, invented the first mechanical lawnmower. Inspired by a machine used to trim the nap off cloth, Budding's design featured a cylindrical blade that rotated as the mower was pushed forward, creating an even cut.
Budding's early grass lawn mowers were primarily used on sports grounds and large estates, as they were heavy and expensive. But as the design evolved, mowers became more affordable and accessible to the general public.
By the late 19th century, lawnmowers had become a common household tool, with various companies producing models with improved efficiency and ease of use.
The early 20th century saw the introduction of petrol-powered lawnmowers, which brought significant advancements in performance and convenience. The petrol engines provided more power, enabling mowers to tackle larger lawns and tougher grass with ease.
Electric lawnmowers entered the scene in the mid-20th century, offering a quieter and more environmentally friendly alternative to petrol models. Early electric lawnmowers were corded, limiting their range and mobility. However, advancements in battery technology led to the development of cordless electric mowers, which combined the benefits of electric power with greater freedom of movement.
Today, both electric and petrol lawnmowers continue to evolve, with manufacturers constantly striving to improve performance, reduce environmental impact, and cater to the diverse needs of garden enthusiasts.
Whether you prefer the quiet, eco-friendly operation of an electric mower or the robust power of a petrol model, there is a lawnmower out there to suit every garden and gardener.
The differences between electric and petrol lawnmowers
When it comes to choosing a lawnmower, deciding between an electric or petrol model is one of the most significant choices you'll face. Each type has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, and the best choice depends on your specific needs and circumstances.
Let's explore the key differences between these two types of lawnmowers:
Cost
One of the first things you'll notice when comparing electric and petrol lawnmowers is the initial cost.
Generally, electric lawnmowers are more affordable upfront than petrol models. This is mainly because electric mowers have simpler designs and fewer mechanical components. However, it's essential to consider long-term costs as well. Electric lawnmowers might incur additional costs for electricity and potential battery replacements.
Petrol lawnmowers, while more expensive initially, may offer greater durability and performance, making them a worthwhile investment for larger lawns, although you will have to factor in the cost of refuelling.
Maintenance
Maintenance is another crucial factor to consider. Electric lawnmowers are typically low-maintenance since they don't require oil changes, spark plug replacements, or fuel management. The most you'll need to do is keep the blades sharp, the mower clean, and occasionally replace the battery if it's a cordless model.
Petrol lawnmowers, on the other hand, demand more regular maintenance. This includes oil changes, air filter replacements, and fuel management. While this may sound like a hassle, it's worth noting that many garden enthusiasts find it relatively straightforward with a bit of practice.
Performance
When it comes to performance, petrol lawnmowers generally have the upper hand, especially for larger lawns and tougher terrain. Petrol engines provide the torque needed to cut through dense patches of grass and tackle uneven surfaces.
Electric lawnmowers, while quieter and more environmentally friendly, may struggle with very long or thick grass. However, advancements in battery technology have improved the performance of cordless electric models, making them more competitive.
Durability
Both electric and petrol lawnmowers can be durable, but their longevity depends on proper maintenance and usage.
Electric lawnmowers tend to have fewer mechanical parts, reducing the risk of wear and tear. With proper care, they can last many years.
Petrol lawnmowers, with their robust engines, can also be long-lasting if well-maintained. Regular servicing, such as oil changes and air filter replacements, is essential for extending the lifespan of petrol mowers.
Proper storage is crucial for both types to protect them from the elements and ensure they remain in good working condition.
Ease of use
The user experience can vary significantly between electric and petrol lawnmowers.
Electric models are generally easier to start and operate, thanks to their simple push-button ignition, which makes them more user-friendly, particularly for those who may find petrol mowers challenging to start. The lightweight design of electric mowers also makes them easier to manoeuvre, reducing fatigue during extended mowing sessions.
Petrol lawnmowers, while more powerful, can be heavier and harder to handle. Starting a petrol mower often involves pulling a cord, which can be physically demanding. However, many users appreciate the raw power and performance of petrol mowers, especially for large and challenging gardens.
Size
Electric lawnmowers are generally lighter and easier to manoeuvre, making them ideal for smaller gardens with tight spots. Their lightweight design allows for easy handling and storage.
Corded electric mowers are particularly useful for small to medium-sized lawns, provided you have access to an outdoor power outlet. Cordless models offer more freedom of movement but require regular recharging.
Petrol lawnmowers are often heavier and bulkier, but they offer greater mobility since they don't require a power cord. This makes them suitable for larger gardens and more demanding tasks.
Another great electric option is the robot lawnmower, which can be programmed to trim your garden down without the need for human input. They can tackle all kinds of terrain, including steep slopes, narrow passages and even the most intricate of garden shapes.
Better yet, they come with handy features, such as a built-in alarm systems, mulching, automatic charging, scheduling functionality, and all-weather operation.
Noise
Noise level is another important consideration, especially if you live in a residential area.
Electric mowers are much quieter than petrol ones, making them a more neighbour-friendly option. The quiet operation also contributes to a more pleasant mowing experience, allowing you to mow at any time without disturbing others.
Petrol lawnmowers, while powerful, can be quite noisy and may not be suitable for noise-sensitive environments. If noise is a concern, an electric lawnmower is likely the better choice.
Power
The power source is a fundamental difference between electric and petrol lawnmowers.
Electric lawnmowers are powered by mains electricity and require a power cord or rechargeable battery. Corded models can provide continuous power so long as they're plugged in, but their range is limited by the length of the power cable. Cordless models offer greater freedom but require regular recharging.
Petrol lawnmowers, on the other hand, use a petrol-powered engine, providing unlimited range and power as long as you have fuel. This makes them more suitable for large gardens and extended mowing sessions.
Environmental impact
Your carbon footprint plays a big role in your day-to-day life, and is becoming an increasingly important consideration for many homeowners.
Electric lawnmowers are more environmentally friendly since they produce zero direct emissions during operation, which makes them an excellent choice if you're looking to reduce your carbon footprint. Additionally, electric mowers are much quieter, reducing noise pollution.
Petrol lawnmowers, on the other hand, emit exhaust fumes and contribute to air pollution. A study on lawnmowers measured the carbon emissions of hand-push, electric, and petrol lawnmowers. Check out the results below:
|
Lawnmower type |
Carbon emissions (kg CO2e) per year |
|
Hand-push |
10.0 |
|
Electric |
14.4 |
|
Petrol |
88 |
The results show just how great the carbon footprint of a petrol lawnmower is when compared to its electric counterpart. If you're environmentally conscious, an electric lawnmower is the better option.
Pros and cons of electric and petrol lawnmowers
Picking the right lawnmower for your garden is a big decision, and understanding the pros and cons of both electric and petrol lawnmowers can help you make an informed choice.
Let's explore the advantages and disadvantages of each:
Pros of electric lawnmowers
-
Environmentally friendly - one of the biggest advantages of electric lawnmowers is their low environmental impact. Electric lawnmowers produce zero direct emissions, with a carbon footprint just slightly higher than a manual hand-push lawnmower, making them a greener option compared to petrol models. This is especially important if you're conscious about reducing your carbon footprint.
-
Quieter operation - electric lawnmowers are significantly quieter than petrol lawnmowers. This can be a major benefit if you live in a residential area and want to avoid disturbing your neighbours. The reduced noise level also makes for a more pleasant mowing experience.
-
Low maintenance - electric lawnmowers require less maintenance compared to their petrol counterparts. There's no need for oil changes, spark plug replacements, or fuel management. Simply keep the blades sharp and the mower clean, and you're good to go.
-
Ease of use - starting an electric lawnmower is as simple as pressing a button. There's no need to struggle with pull cords or worry about the engine not starting. This makes electric lawnmowers more user-friendly, particularly for those who may find petrol mowers challenging to start.
-
Lightweight - electric lawnmowers are generally lighter and easier to manoeuvre than petrol models, which is ideal for those small to medium-sized gardens with tight spots and obstacles.
-
Lower operating costs - while electric lawnmowers may have higher electricity costs, they tend to be cheaper to operate in the long run compared to petrol mowers. There's no need to purchase fuel, and maintenance costs are typically lower.
Cons of electric lawnmowers
-
Limited runtime (battery-powered models) - battery-operated electric lawnmowers have limited runtime, typically ranging from 30 to 60 minutes, depending on the model and battery capacity. This can be a drawback for larger gardens, as you'll need to recharge the battery before continuing.
-
Dependency on power source (corded models) - corded electric lawnmowers are limited by the length of the power cable, which can restrict your range and mobility. This can be an issue if you have a larger garden or need to mow areas far from a power outlet.
-
Less Power - electric lawnmowers generally have less power compared to petrol models. They may struggle with very thick or long grass, making them less suitable for tough mowing conditions.
-
Battery degradation - over time, the batteries in electric lawnmowers can degrade, leading to reduced performance and shorter runtime. Replacing the batteries can be costly, adding to the long-term operating expenses.
Pros of petrol lawnmowers
-
High Power - petrol lawnmowers are known for their powerful engines, making them ideal for tackling thick grass, weeds, and uneven terrain. They can handle tough mowing conditions with ease, making them a preferred choice for larger gardens.
-
Longer runtime - unlike battery-operated electric lawnmowers, petrol mowers can run for extended periods without needing a recharge. This makes them suitable for large lawns and extended mowing sessions.
-
Mobility - petrol lawnmowers are not restricted by power cords or battery life, giving you greater freedom to mow anywhere in your garden to your heart’s content. This versatility is particularly useful for gardens with multiple sections or areas far from power outlets.
-
Durability - petrol lawnmowers are often more robust and durable than electric models. With proper maintenance, a good-quality petrol mower can last for many years, making it a long-term investment.
Cons of petrol lawnmowers
-
Environmental impact - petrol lawnmowers fall short in their carbon footprint. They produce exhaust emissions, contributing to air pollution and climate change. Their carbon footprint is nearly eight times larger than electric lawnmowers. If you're environmentally conscious, this might be a significant concern.
-
Noise - petrol lawnmowers are much noisier than electric models. This can be a disadvantage if you live in a residential area or prefer a quieter mowing experience. The noise can also be bothersome during extended mowing sessions.
-
Maintenance - petrol lawnmowers require regular maintenance, including oil changes, spark plug replacements, and air filter cleaning. This adds to the overall cost and effort needed to keep the mower in good working condition.
-
Weight - petrol lawnmowers are typically heavier and bulkier than electric models. This can make them more challenging to manoeuvre, especially in tight spaces or around obstacles. The weight can also make them harder to transport and store.
-
Starting - starting a petrol lawnmower often involves pulling a cord, which can be physically demanding and frustrating if the engine doesn't start on the first try. This can be a significant disadvantage for users who prefer a more straightforward, hassle-free operation.
Both electric and petrol lawnmowers have their pros and cons, and the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences.
Electric lawnmowers are environmentally friendly, quieter, and easier to maintain, making them ideal for small to medium-sized gardens.
Petrol lawnmowers, on the other hand, offer more power, longer runtime, and greater versatility, making them suitable for larger gardens and tougher mowing conditions.
What to consider when choosing a lawnmower
Choosing the right lawnmower can be a bit of a head-scratcher, but don't worry. Here are some practical points to think about before you make that purchase:
What does your garden need?
Start by evaluating the size and type of your garden. If you have a small to medium-sized garden, an electric lawnmower will do the job nicely, providing efficient and quieter operation.
For larger gardens with tougher terrain, a petrol lawnmower might be more suitable due to its powerful engine and greater mobility. If your lawn has lots of curves or obstacles, consider a model with good manoeuvrability.
What is your budget?
Think about your budget, both initial and long-term. Electric lawnmowers generally have lower upfront costs and maintenance expenses, while petrol lawnmowers, though pricier initially, may offer greater durability and power.
Remember to factor in the cost of electricity or fuel over time. Balance the costs with the features you need and the performance you expect, and don’t forget to check the warranty options for added peace of mind.
What additional features do you want?
Consider additional features that can enhance your mowing experience.
Look for self-propelled models to reduce the effort required, mulching capabilities to help feed your lawn, adjustable cutting heights for a tailored cut, and wider cutting widths to reduce mowing time.
Some models even come with grass collectors to keep your garden tidy and folding handles for easy storage.
How much storage space do you have?
Consider the storage space you have available. Electric lawnmowers are typically more compact and easier to store, ideal for smaller sheds or garages. Petrol lawnmowers may require more room due to their larger size and additional fuel storage needs.
Make sure you have a dry, secure place to keep your mower, and consider models with foldable handles or compact designs if space is at a premium.
Shop lawnmowers at Hughie Willett Machinery
Choosing between an electric and petrol lawnmower ultimately comes down to your specific needs and preferences.
Electric lawnmowers offer environmental benefits, low maintenance, and ease of use, making them suitable for small to medium-sized gardens. They're also quieter and more neighbour-friendly, ideal for residential areas.
Petrol lawnmowers provide high power, versatility, and longer runtime, making them suitable for larger gardens and tough mowing conditions. They offer greater mobility and can handle dense grass and uneven terrain with ease.
Explore Hughie Willett’s range of electric and petrol lawnmowers to find the perfect match for your garden. Our selection includes top brands and models designed to cater to various gardening needs. Contact our customer service team for personalized advice and take advantage of any ongoing promotions or discounts.
Shop Lawnmowers at Hughie Willett Machinery
For more information about ground care machinery and equipment buying guides and advice, explore the Hughie Willett Machinery blog…
The Ultimate Guide to Buying a Chainsaw | The Complete Hedge Trimmer Buying Guide | The Ultimate Guide to Buying a Ride On Lawn Mower